roanoke.com
 


 News
   Front Page
   Roanoke Valley
   New River Valley
   vt.roanoke.com
   AP News
   Neighbors

   Celebrations
   Politics
   Road Watch
   Special Reports
 
 Sports
 Entertainment
 Columnists
 Outdoors
 Business
 Obituaries
 Community
 Travel
 Health
 Classifieds
 Dining Guide
 Yellow Pages
 jobs.roanoke.com
Search


Great expectations

By BARNIE DAY
AUG. 25, 2003

Barnie Day was a Democratic delegate from Patrick County from his election in 1997 through the 2001 session. A former county administrator and business owner, he is now a banker.
“It is not the powerful arm, but soft enchanting tongue that governs all.”
— Sophocles (495-406 B.C.)

The power of spoken communication has been recognized for a long time.

Says Homer in the Iliad, sometime between the 10th and the 8th Century, B. C.: “When his words fell soft as snowflakes on a winter’s day, then could no mortal man beside vie with Odysseus.”

Maybe so. But a few could give Ody his comeuppance.

Lincoln, at Gettysburg, surely. Churchill? Hands down. The Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. is, in the English language, incomparable. And, sure, I know what a broad swath of literature that includes.

The most memorable speeches, the ones that move people, that inspire them, are political. Perhaps it is because only politics can move nations.

Sometimes the direction of the move is hellish. See Hitler’s Germany. Sometimes, not quite so. See Castro’s “History Will Absolve Me” speech at the time of his first arrest. (Then his only real claim to fame was high school athlete of the year in Cuba.)

Perhaps the power of speech is in inverse proportion to the fear most people have of giving them. Public speaking routinely ranks in front of snakes and spiders on phobia surveys.

It may be something a little stronger. Harriet Beecher Stowe (1811-1896), herself no slouch, opined that it may be sexual. Said she: “If ever a woman feels proud of her lover, it is when she sees him as a successful public speaker.”

Translation: may be a good way to pick up chicks.

Great speeches, or at least phrases of them, hang in the mind. Politically, some are capable of pulling the chestnuts out of the fire. See Nixon’s “Checkers” speech, wherein he blubbers on about his wife’s “good, Republican coat.”

Some, clearly, can push the chestnuts into the fire. Bush The First: “Read my lips. No new taxes.” Bush The Second: sixteen little words that everybody from the doorman to the National Security Adviser has claimed so far.

Some soar. Kennedy’s inaugural stand-up; Kennedy in Berlin. Some hit with the thud of…well… See Goldwater’s “extremism,” vice-virtue debacle.

Speech-making is like bull-riding. Both can be exhilarating; both can break your back. Time is warped by perspective. Eight seconds seems like a blink, unless you’re on the bull.

In bull-riding, the bull gets 50 points and the rider gets 50. Same with speakers and speeches.

The immortals write their own. Easy to imagine Lincoln scratching away. Churchill won the only Nobel Prize for Literature that cited “the spoken word.” Any doubt that King wrote his is dispelled by the reading of his “Letter From a Birmingham Jail.”

Still, rare magic happens when great writers converge with great “givers”, when that twain shall meet.

It happened often with Ronald Regan, the Great Communicator, the “Morning in America” man, and Peggy Noonan, a gifted writer. Who could forget Reagan’s soaring, searing rhetoric after the first shuttle tragedy?

Jimmy Carter couldn’t buy the convergence. He could never get over that annoying habit of flaring his eyes for verbal emphasis. Still can’t.

We had a touch, if not of greatness, then at least informed grace, here in Virginia the other day.

Sen. John Chichester, powerful chairman of Senate Finance, who learned a thing or two about state finances at the knee of former chairman Hunter Andrews (who learned at the knee of the quintessential chairman, Ed Willey), gave a sock-o stand-up to the Virginia Foundation for Research and Economic Education (Virginia FREE).

The most important speech given in Virginia this year, it met with near universal acclaim.

(Three of the state’s major daily newspapers — in Roanoke, Norfolk, and Newport News — led their Sunday opinion sections with it).

Said he: “Resources will never be limitless; we will always need to set priorities and make choices. But we are way overdue to begin the conversation about what we want Virginia to look like 10 or 15 years from now.”

Count that one as reality converging with common sense.

Let any elected or appointed official know what you think and how you feel by clicking here.

The Day Archive

A message to Congress

Gourmet politics

Rubbish

Tax reform: Can she sing? Can she dance?

Disturbing pattern emerging

Ready! Aim at your foot! Fire!

Make room, ostriches!

The 'tar-baby' strategy

Enough with the gamesmanship

Hold on, Mr. Speaker!

Watch these three

Virginia FREE! At last! At last!

My money's on Bob

Zen Republicans

Thanks for going

The Jim and Shirley Show

Not a bad day

Blame it on Tom and Ed

Word games

Memo to the candidates

Democrats take the Senate -- in 30 words

Veto the budget

The swindle

Partisan ambush derails two terms

The Marcy maxim

Curiouser and curiouser!

Justice's dirty little secret

Poster boys

A lesson from Luke

That Allen two-step

A Lott to think about

'Tis the season of Republican discontent

Democrats must embrace education

Democrats must dissent

Jack be nimble, Jack be quick

Why Democrats lose. Why Republicans win.

Toward a new agenda

Nancy Jane

Get the crow ready

This game of political chicken

Worthy of a legacy

Take down 'Cooter's' flag, if naught but for courtesy

Republicans waiting in the weeds

A letter to the presidents of Virginia's public colleges and universities

If today is Wednesday, we must be in Rio

The shot fired back

Cool Head Luke redux

Cool Head Luke: a continuing play

Requiem

North of a billion

Ignatius, phone home

Kilgore out front, except when it matters

A letter from Cornbread

The shakedown game

A circle closes

A nail is loose in Fairfax!

Bay-beee!!!!!

Bon jour

Don't weaken speakership

What's that smell, Alice?

Money masher

Democrats will pick the next speaker









Copyright 2003
Privacy Policy | Contact Us